The Art of War, and Yes, there IS such a thing as a dumb question...

Posted by Nancy M on January 24, 2002 at 18:08:33:

This question has occurred to me any time that I've seen a movie with Colonial-era soldiers fighting. I know that this will sound like a dumb question to some of you military history buffs, but I'll put the question out there, and wait for you to enlighten me...!

OK---in scenes where soldiers are fighting, like the ambush scene in LOTM, the soldiers load their muskets, wait, and fire when ordered to "FIRE!". Then, they reload, kind of standing out there as a sitting target, at which point, some of them are shot and drop dead. Now, I know that armies have strategies and discipline, but I don't get this---standing there reloading and being shot at. It does, however, really make me appreciate the bravery of those soldiers! In a more modern war movie, you'd see soldiers shooting, then taking cover to reload.

So, I guess my dumb question is---what was the strategy there? Was that the traditional way that fighting/shooting was done? And when did it change---when weaponry changed? Or when casualties got too high?

I recently went to see the re-enactments of the Battles of Trenton, and I saw the same sort of thing---they fire on command, reload, and get shot at while standing out in the open! Firing the muskets all at one time was formidable, but the reloading gets me.....!

BTW--the re-enactments were great! Cannons and muskets firing, and soldiers marching through downtown Trenton--what a sight! You could really get a sense of what a battle was like.

Anyway, thanks in advance to any of you military-types who care to comment.

Nancy

Follow Ups:

• Re: The Art of War, and Yes, there IS such a thing as a dumb question... Edmund McKinnon 15:03:27 1/25/2002 (0)
• Re: The Art of War, and Yes, there IS such a thing as a dumb question... Sarah M. 20:35:55 1/24/2002 (0)
• Re: The Art of War, and Yes, there IS such a thing as a dumb question... Lt. Col. John Armstrong 18:43:56 1/24/2002 (5)
  • Re: The Art of War, and Yes, there IS such a thing as a dumb question... Two Kettles 19:59:52 1/24/2002 (4)
    • Re: The Art of War, and Yes, there IS such a thing as a dumb question... Pvt. Chauncey 20:32:09 1/24/2002 (3)
      • Re: The Art of War, and Yes, there IS such a thing as a dumb question... Lt. Col. Armstrong 21:54:55 1/24/2002 (0)
      • Re: The Art of War, and Yes, there IS such a thing as a dumb question... Lt. Col. Armstrong 21:53:59 1/24/2002 (1)
        • Re: The Art of War, and Yes, there IS such a thing as a dumb question... Nancy M 17:40:58 1/27/2002 (0)

Post a Followup

Name    : 
E-Mail  : 
Subject : 

Comments:
: This question has occurred to me any time that I've seen a movie with Colonial-era soldiers fighting.  I know that this will sound like a dumb question to some of you military history buffs, but I'll put the question out there, and wait for you to enlighten me...!

: OK---in scenes where soldiers are fighting, like the ambush scene in LOTM, the soldiers load their muskets, wait, and fire when ordered to "FIRE!".  Then, they reload, kind of standing out there as a sitting target, at which point, some of them are shot and drop dead.  Now, I know that armies have strategies and discipline, but I don't get this---standing there reloading and being shot at. It does, however, really make me appreciate the bravery of those soldiers!  In a more modern war movie, you'd see soldiers shooting, then taking cover to reload.

: So, I guess my dumb question is---what was the strategy there?  Was that the traditional way that fighting/shooting was done?  And when did it change---when weaponry changed?  Or when casualties got too high?

: I recently went to see the re-enactments of the Battles of Trenton, and I saw the same sort of thing---they fire on command, reload, and get shot at while standing out in the open!  Firing the muskets all at one time was formidable, but the reloading gets me.....!

: BTW--the re-enactments were great!  Cannons and muskets firing, and soldiers marching through downtown Trenton--what a sight!  You could really get a sense of what a battle was like.

: Anyway, thanks in advance to any of you military-types who care to comment.

: Nancy


Optional Link URL:  
Link Title:         
Optional Image URL: